Eyeliner Comparison

I love eyeliner ! I think everyone love eyeliner too.. :D
But, search an eyeliner that match with our eye skin is not easy.. I have tried so many eyeliner pencil, gel, and liquid to find the most suitable eyeliner with my eyes >.<

I want to do some comparison with my pencil eyeliner..

Eyeliner that I will compare :
1. Pixy colors of delights eyeliner ~ this is my first eyeliner when I know make up.. :p

2. Etude House drawing show creamy pencil GR701

3. Etude House Proof 10 Auto Pencil BK801

4 Milani Liquif'eye metalic eye liner pencil ~ black

I already read some review about Milani liquif'eye, and the result is very waterproof and smodgeproof. But, is it better than another pencil eyeliner? Let's check it :)

First, I will swatch on my hand.. I didn't put any primer before..

From le - ri : pixy, drawing show, proof 10, milani

comparison for color intensity :

pixy : good enough ~ love the black color

drawing show : I love the green color, and the glitter of course..

proof 10 : the color is not really out.. 

milani : the black is very strong.. Love it :D

the winner : milani

Second, I will do waterproof test.. 

Nothing changes, the eyeliner still on the place

After I rub my hand, the pixy is going fade.. 

the result:

pixy : bad.. can't resist the water

drawing show , proof 10, milani : still on the place

the winner : draw between drawing show, proof 10 and milani :o

Last but not least, I rub my hand hardly to test the smudgeproof

pixy : disappear :3

After doing that three test on my eyeliner pencil.. The winner is........

Hmm.. I confuse between milani and drawing show.. lol.. 

But I think the winner is drawing show creamy pencil.. It still stand on my eyes even I didn't use any primer. How about milani? It stay on my eyes too, but sometimes it still smudge..  I love both of them ♥

How about you? :D

♥xoxo♥